Prabowo calls online gambling a national sinkhole as US$8B flows out. Indonesia freezes accounts and blocks domains while weighing legalization. Andy's take.
News Brief
Indonesian President Prabowo recently went all guns blazing in public — a rare sight — calling online gambling as a national-level "sinkhole" for Indonesia. He banged the table and said this is no "harmless little online pastime." Why is Indonesia so worked up this time? US$8 billion flowing out of the country is no joke — that’s real money shooting out of Indonesia on a rocket! Let’s run through these points:
- Capital outflow: Last time Japan’s 7.7 billion-plus dollars was already bad enough, and in the blink of an eye Indonesia has blown an 8 billion dollar hole of its own. The money is flying out as if it had wings — what are they supposed to do?
- Money laundering on the side: These people are so bold they’d "have the mouse be the cat’s bridesmaid," and they go straight for honest people’s wallets.
- Social problems: Families broken up, jobs lost, society losing its shirt — it’s like someone hauling off the money jar hidden under your bed mat, nest and all!
- Young people hooked: Once young people fall in, it’s like stepping into a tar pit. Want to pull your leg out? It’s harder than getting my hometown village party secretary to solve calculus.
- Academics pile on too: These ruthless online-gambling operators deliberately target people who are naïve and don’t have much money. It’s not that the players are "badly addicted" — it’s like Zhang Fei conning raw recruits: works every time!
Going Hard in Public
The Indonesian government has put together a full set of moves: right after vowing a tough crackdown, it "rolled up its sleeves" and got to work — freezing gambling accounts, blocking domains, tracing money flows, forcing banks to recite "KYC" like a tightening-headband spell, and on top of that bringing the telecoms and financial bodies together for a "party"!
Quietly Looking for a Way Out
What’s even more striking is that, behind the scenes, Indonesian officials are already mulling giving gambling a "household registration"! But for now it’s only a hint, and nobody dares make a fuss for fear the villagers will grab their hoes and tear the roof off the village committee office.
The Road Ahead for Indonesia
I think Indonesia will sooner or later discuss regulating it, because:
- Crackdowns can suppress the market, but demand won’t disappear
- With profits at stake, the more grey platforms are banned, the wilder they get
- The social cost is too high
So can Japan’s approach be copied in Indonesia? I’ll be blunt: no.
Because Japan maintains stability through ‘rules + social pressure,’ and social pressure there is as strong as the public backlash against groping on trains — dare to reach out a hand and the whole carriage will zap you with moral rays until sparks fly.
Indonesia is different. It needs a four-part approach: "regulation + education + technology + international cooperation" — just like road-building back in my hometown: putting up a sign isn’t enough. If you don’t send a couple of old guys to sit there on little stools keeping watch, even the dogs will walk right across it.
Andy's Chit-Chat
Folks, Indonesia has been hit hard by online gambling this time. Last time Japan’s 7.7 billion-plus dollars was already bad enough, and in no time Indonesia blew an 8 billion dollar hole of its own. The money is flying out as if it had wings, criminal gangs are laundering money brazenly — like a mouse serving as the cat’s bridesmaid," ordinary families’ savings are being scraped clean, and young people who fall in and try to pull thfeir legs out? Harder than getting my hometown village party secretary to solve calculus. But guess what? While the government is "rolling up its sleeves’ for a crackdown, officials are also quietly considering whether to give gambling a ‘household registration and an ID card"!
Actually, I’d be quite happy to see that happen. Why? Because for Indonesia, as long as it’s done properly, the benefits outweigh the costs. Think about it: these grey platforms are like weeds right now — the more you ban them the more they grow, the more you pull them the thicker they get. Some players don’t care about the rules either way and keep playing under the covers. Rather than letting the gangs drink all the soup, it’s better for the government to "set the rules, collect the taxes and regulate" — at least that’s heading in the right direction.
What’s it like? It’s like the smelly ditch at the village entrance: cover it with a plank and it still bubbles away underneath; but turn it into a proper fish pond, and not only does the water get cleaner, you can catch a few fish at year-end to improve your meals. Whether it’s a ditch or gambling, only once it’s brought into the open can it be managed.
Some people worry that legalization will make everyone gamble. The way I see it, the principle here is "blocking is worse than channelling, and channelling is worse than guiding." Putting gambling on the table, setting clear thresholds, wiping out illegal ads and tightly controlling money flows is actually far cleaner than today’s situation of "sealed shut on the surface, chaos underneath." The key is that Indonesia shouldn’t take Japan’s route — there a train groper gets struck by moral lightning the moment he reaches out. Indonesia needs "regulation that goes for the jugular, education that keeps spreading the message, technology that filters risks layer by layer, and international cooperation that builds a fence" — a four-part approach.
Our Indonesian friends will have to take this road sooner or later. Rather than playing "cat and mouse" with grey platforms every day, it’s better to set the rules properly early on. The industry can play however it likes, but it has to be above board on the table, not everyone hiding in corners. What Indonesia needs to do now is clear up this murky situation, bring the activity into the open and regulate it — fast!
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did Indonesia's president suddenly go all guns blazing and crack down hard on online gambling?
The Indonesian president called out online gambling because the country faces a capital outflow of as much as US$8 billion, which has triggered serious social crises including money laundering, broken families and young people getting hooked. These grey platforms deliberately target people who are naïve and don’t have much money, causing huge amounts of wealth to fly away as if on wings and forcing the government to step in.
What concrete crackdown measures has the Indonesian government taken against online gambling in public?
In public the Indonesian government has taken a full set of crackdown measures, including freezing gambling accounts, blocking domains, tracing money flows and forcing banks to treat KYC verification like a tightening-headband spell. At the same time, it has brought telecoms, financial and other bodies together to launch a tough joint offensive.
Could Indonesia follow Japan's model to deal with online gambling in the future?
Indonesia cannot simply copy Japan’s model of maintaining stability through rules plus social pressure, because the two countries’ social environments are very different. In the future Indonesia will need a four-in-one combination of regulation, education, technology and international cooperation to truly rein in these wildly growing grey platforms.
Why does the industry expect Indonesia to consider regulating online gambling sooner or later?
Because pure suppression can restrain the market but cannot make real demand disappear, and instead makes grey platforms grow wilder the more they are banned. Rather than letting huge sums drain away and the gangs drink the soup, it is better for the government to step in to set rules, collect taxes and regulate, bringing the underground industry into the open to be managed.
To bring online gambling onto the table and manage it, what specific approach does Indonesia need?
If Indonesia moves toward regulation, it cannot rely on sealing things shut on the surface; it needs regulation that goes for the jugular, education that is promoted every day, technology that filters layer by layer and a tight fence of international cooperation. Like braising a goose, not a single step can be skipped, so the whole situation can be stirred up, cleared and brought into the light.
